A grieving North Carolina mother who recently had her personal injury case denied by several firms due to contributory negligence, is hoping her Change.org petition will rewrite the law that has forced numerous injury claims to get denied – claims that had substantial merit.

Unlike states that adopt the doctrine of contributory negligence, which allows plaintiffs to receive compensation commensurate with their liability in accidents, North Carolina personal injury laws are stiffer. As Mignon Elkes quickly discovered, her daughter’s partial fault turned into a no-win situation, even though evidence supported willful negligence on the driver’s behalf. She was wearing all black and walking with her back toward traffic late at night.

As potential clients of ours see stories like this, we would like to clear the air regarding how contributory negligence plays into personal injury matters, and what steps can be taken if you are facing an uphill battle proving no negligence occurred from your end.

Theories of Negligence

Experienced personal injury attorneys never stop looking for ways to emerge victorious for clients who deserve justice. That is just their pedigree. With that said, and based on evidence collected surrounding a defendant’s injury claim, negligence can exist in one or several ways:

  • Contributorily: Negligence that is even 1% the defendant’s is adjudicated as contributory in nature, meaning although someone else caused an injury, the defendant had some control over the creation of the scenario that caused said injury. These cases can be defeated, which we will explain shortly.
  • Willfully: This means someone else was responsible for the care and safety of the defendant, and recklessly abused that responsibility.
  • Comparably: Although not practiced in North Carolina, comparable negligence means the defendant, regardless if partially responsible, is owed monies based on their role in their own personal injury. Juries may award 1%, up to 99%, of a total dollar amount and give that to defendant based on how faultful they believe the defendant was.

One well-documented method of defeating contributory negligence cases in North Carolina is by a seldom-used ‘last clear chance doctrine’ defense. When an attorney raises this defense during arguments, enough information exists that puts the client in a position of peril, with no chance of avoiding an accident, while the defendant fails to do his or her part in avoiding the creation of an accident or injury.

Various levels of negligence and varying scenarios will dictate how an attorney can help recover compensation for his or her clients.

Suggested Courses of Action if Personally Injured

How victims of personal injury react after their respective incidents are important to how effectively an attorney can defend their cases. For example, an individual who absconds after an auto accident is less likely to win an injury claim than someone who helped others from their wrecked vehicles in spite of his or her own battered condition.

To win cases in which contributory negligence defenses may be used, plaintiffs should always:

  • Preserve evidence in whatever manner seems ethical;
  • Get witness contact information;
  • Be prepared to prove their lives were in peril, or accident avoidance was impossible;
  • Speak nothing of their case to anyone without an attorney’s consent or blessing. You would be surprised what can (and will) be used against you.

Follow all laws, and the law will work for you.

Call a North Carolina Personal Injury Attorney Today

Retaining the efficient legal representation of Rawls, Scheer, Clary, & Mingo means personally injured persons in Charlotte, across North Carolina and throughout America receive zealous representation. As legal advocates with proven trial experience, we have never needed to chase ambulances to win cases for deserving clients.

Our goal is simple: establish an unbreakable attorney-client bond.

Contributory negligence is one of North Carolina’s most contentious laws, as we discovered earlier with Mignon Elkes. If you feel that an at-fault party may raise this argument in court, but have information contradicting that claim, call our firm immediately.

See other related blogs:

READ MORE  How Criminal Defense Attorneys Minimize Pretrial Publicity

Getting legal help for personal injuries in Charlotte

Car Accident: What To Do Immediately After

 

Read Reviews of Our Law Firm

Featured Articles
"I thought RSFM was the only Law Firm in Charlotte!! They have been my Attorney's for many year's & I have alway's been pleased with there professionalism!! I have also referred many of my associate's to them as well and they have also been very pleased with there representation of there legal affair's!! I consider this Law Firm not only my Friend's but my Family! Especially that really tall Eben & that short guy Tony!! Love you Guy's!!!"
"I want to thank you all for saving my life....I know you went to considerable effort and expended considerable energy and time to obtain the best possible resolution for me, and that this process was not straightforward and required great skill to accomplish. I know that you believed in me, did not waver in your belief in me, and articulated this belief clearly and effectively when it mattered most. I know that you put your heart into this. You did not see me as a criminal, but as a human being, and in many ways, I felt, as a colleague." ...
"Tony Scheer and his team handled my case with expertise and professionalism. At one of the most difficult times of my life, I was able to rely on his wonderful guidance and heart felt support like I was part of his family in trouble. The people at RSFM go to great lengths to get the most desirable outcome possible for your case and hardly take “no” for an answer. They were relentless in working for my benefit in my case. He was able to get a great deal for me. To this day, I can always count on Tony and ...
"I was in an accident in November of 2010. It quickly became evident that this was going to be an ongoing issue and after only 2 days I was feeling the pressure of the decisions I was faced with. I was given Amanda Mingo’s name and number from my husband’s coworker. I felt comfortable with her right away. She was empathetic and sympathetic and made handing all of this pressure over to her easy, so I could focus on healing. Over the next 3 years I was kept informed and had a say in every turn that my case took. ...
"I want to thank you all for saving my life....I know you went to considerable effort and expended considerable energy and time to obtain the best possible resolution for me, and that this process was not straightforward and required great skill to accomplish. I know that you believed in me, did not waver in your belief in me, and articulated this belief clearly and effectively when it mattered most. I know that you put your heart into this. You did not see me as a criminal, but as a human being, and in many ways, I felt, as a colleague." ...
The information you obtain at this site is not, nor is it intended to be, legal advice. You should consult an attorney for advice regarding your individual situation. We invite you to contact us and welcome your calls, letters and electronic mail. Contacting us does not create an attorney-client relationship. Please do not send any confidential information to us until such time as an attorney-client relationship has been established.